A Strange Mistake in Application of Residue theorem $int_0^2pifrac cos(2theta) 5+4cos(theta), dtheta.$ [closed]

The name of the pictureThe name of the pictureThe name of the pictureClash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP











up vote
3
down vote

favorite
2













$$int_0^2pifrac cos(2theta) 5+4cos(theta), dtheta.$$




While applying the calculus of residues to the above problem I'm getting the answer as
$ 19pi/24$. I have tried many times and rechecked the calculations but getting the same answer.



However in my book the answer given is $pi/6.$



Can someone check and tell me whether I'm correct or the book? Please help.







share|cite|improve this question













closed as off-topic by spaceisdarkgreen, Claude Leibovici, Jose Arnaldo Bebita Dris, Delta-u, Taroccoesbrocco Jul 25 at 9:30


This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:


  • "This question is missing context or other details: Please improve the question by providing additional context, which ideally includes your thoughts on the problem and any attempts you have made to solve it. This information helps others identify where you have difficulties and helps them write answers appropriate to your experience level." – spaceisdarkgreen, Claude Leibovici, Jose Arnaldo Bebita Dris, Delta-u, Taroccoesbrocco
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.








  • 1




    The book is correct.
    – uniquesolution
    Jul 24 at 13:35






  • 1




    The command Integrate[Cos[2t]/(5+4Cos[t]),t,0,2Pi] in Mathematica shows that the book is correct. Why don't you post some of your working so we can look at it?
    – Adrian Keister
    Jul 24 at 13:59










  • If you don't show any work, it is impossible to say where you are making your mistake...
    – paul garrett
    Jul 24 at 16:44














up vote
3
down vote

favorite
2













$$int_0^2pifrac cos(2theta) 5+4cos(theta), dtheta.$$




While applying the calculus of residues to the above problem I'm getting the answer as
$ 19pi/24$. I have tried many times and rechecked the calculations but getting the same answer.



However in my book the answer given is $pi/6.$



Can someone check and tell me whether I'm correct or the book? Please help.







share|cite|improve this question













closed as off-topic by spaceisdarkgreen, Claude Leibovici, Jose Arnaldo Bebita Dris, Delta-u, Taroccoesbrocco Jul 25 at 9:30


This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:


  • "This question is missing context or other details: Please improve the question by providing additional context, which ideally includes your thoughts on the problem and any attempts you have made to solve it. This information helps others identify where you have difficulties and helps them write answers appropriate to your experience level." – spaceisdarkgreen, Claude Leibovici, Jose Arnaldo Bebita Dris, Delta-u, Taroccoesbrocco
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.








  • 1




    The book is correct.
    – uniquesolution
    Jul 24 at 13:35






  • 1




    The command Integrate[Cos[2t]/(5+4Cos[t]),t,0,2Pi] in Mathematica shows that the book is correct. Why don't you post some of your working so we can look at it?
    – Adrian Keister
    Jul 24 at 13:59










  • If you don't show any work, it is impossible to say where you are making your mistake...
    – paul garrett
    Jul 24 at 16:44












up vote
3
down vote

favorite
2









up vote
3
down vote

favorite
2






2






$$int_0^2pifrac cos(2theta) 5+4cos(theta), dtheta.$$




While applying the calculus of residues to the above problem I'm getting the answer as
$ 19pi/24$. I have tried many times and rechecked the calculations but getting the same answer.



However in my book the answer given is $pi/6.$



Can someone check and tell me whether I'm correct or the book? Please help.







share|cite|improve this question














$$int_0^2pifrac cos(2theta) 5+4cos(theta), dtheta.$$




While applying the calculus of residues to the above problem I'm getting the answer as
$ 19pi/24$. I have tried many times and rechecked the calculations but getting the same answer.



However in my book the answer given is $pi/6.$



Can someone check and tell me whether I'm correct or the book? Please help.









share|cite|improve this question












share|cite|improve this question




share|cite|improve this question








edited Aug 2 at 12:08









user 108128

18.8k41544




18.8k41544









asked Jul 24 at 13:30









johny

515




515




closed as off-topic by spaceisdarkgreen, Claude Leibovici, Jose Arnaldo Bebita Dris, Delta-u, Taroccoesbrocco Jul 25 at 9:30


This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:


  • "This question is missing context or other details: Please improve the question by providing additional context, which ideally includes your thoughts on the problem and any attempts you have made to solve it. This information helps others identify where you have difficulties and helps them write answers appropriate to your experience level." – spaceisdarkgreen, Claude Leibovici, Jose Arnaldo Bebita Dris, Delta-u, Taroccoesbrocco
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.




closed as off-topic by spaceisdarkgreen, Claude Leibovici, Jose Arnaldo Bebita Dris, Delta-u, Taroccoesbrocco Jul 25 at 9:30


This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:


  • "This question is missing context or other details: Please improve the question by providing additional context, which ideally includes your thoughts on the problem and any attempts you have made to solve it. This information helps others identify where you have difficulties and helps them write answers appropriate to your experience level." – spaceisdarkgreen, Claude Leibovici, Jose Arnaldo Bebita Dris, Delta-u, Taroccoesbrocco
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.







  • 1




    The book is correct.
    – uniquesolution
    Jul 24 at 13:35






  • 1




    The command Integrate[Cos[2t]/(5+4Cos[t]),t,0,2Pi] in Mathematica shows that the book is correct. Why don't you post some of your working so we can look at it?
    – Adrian Keister
    Jul 24 at 13:59










  • If you don't show any work, it is impossible to say where you are making your mistake...
    – paul garrett
    Jul 24 at 16:44












  • 1




    The book is correct.
    – uniquesolution
    Jul 24 at 13:35






  • 1




    The command Integrate[Cos[2t]/(5+4Cos[t]),t,0,2Pi] in Mathematica shows that the book is correct. Why don't you post some of your working so we can look at it?
    – Adrian Keister
    Jul 24 at 13:59










  • If you don't show any work, it is impossible to say where you are making your mistake...
    – paul garrett
    Jul 24 at 16:44







1




1




The book is correct.
– uniquesolution
Jul 24 at 13:35




The book is correct.
– uniquesolution
Jul 24 at 13:35




1




1




The command Integrate[Cos[2t]/(5+4Cos[t]),t,0,2Pi] in Mathematica shows that the book is correct. Why don't you post some of your working so we can look at it?
– Adrian Keister
Jul 24 at 13:59




The command Integrate[Cos[2t]/(5+4Cos[t]),t,0,2Pi] in Mathematica shows that the book is correct. Why don't you post some of your working so we can look at it?
– Adrian Keister
Jul 24 at 13:59












If you don't show any work, it is impossible to say where you are making your mistake...
– paul garrett
Jul 24 at 16:44




If you don't show any work, it is impossible to say where you are making your mistake...
– paul garrett
Jul 24 at 16:44










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes

















up vote
3
down vote



accepted










If $varphi(x,y)=fracx^2-y^25+4x$, then your integral is$$int_0^2pivarphi(costheta,sintheta),mathrm dtheta.tag1$$Let$$f(z)=frac1zvarphileft(fracz+z^-12,fracz-z^-12iright)$$and$$beginarrayrcccgammacolon&[0,2pi]&longrightarrow&mathbb C\&theta&mapsto&e^itheta.endarray$$Then$$varphi(costheta,sintheta)=varphileft(frace^itheta+e^-itheta2,frace^itheta-e^-itheta2iright)=e^ithetafleft(e^ithetaright).$$Thereforebeginalign(1)&=frac1iint_0^2pie^-ithetavarphileft(frace^itheta+e^-itheta2,frace^itheta-e^-itheta2iright)ie^itheta,mathrm dtheta\&=-iint_gamma f(z),mathrm dz.endalignThis integral can be computed through the residue theorem: it is equal to$$2pisumoperatornameres_z=chibigl(f(z)bigr),tag2$$where the possible values of $chi$ are the poles of $f$ in the open unit circle. But$$f(z)=fracz^4+1z^2(4z^2+10z+4).$$So, $f$ has $3$ poles, two of which are located at the open unit circle: $0$ and $-frac12$ (the third one is $-2$) and the residue of $f$ at these points is $frac1724$ and $-frac58$ respectively. Therefore, your integral is equal to$$2pileft(frac1724-frac58right)=fracpi6.$$






share|cite|improve this answer






























    up vote
    4
    down vote













    Use substitutions $z=e^itheta$ and $dtheta=dfracdziz$ then
    beginalign
    int_0^2pifrac cos(2theta) 5+4cos(theta), dtheta
    &= bf Reint_dfracz^25+4(z+1/z)dfracdziz \
    &= bf Redfrac1iint_dfracfracz^22(z+2)z+1/2dz \
    &= bf Redfrac1i2pi idfrac(-frac12)^23 \
    &= colorbluedfracpi6
    endalign






    share|cite|improve this answer























    • By "Re" do you mean Res(.) ? I always read Re as the real part. So just clearing things up
      – William
      Aug 2 at 13:33










    • It's real part.
      – user 108128
      Aug 2 at 13:34










    • sorry for the trouble again, but shouldn't the numerator be $z^2 - i sin theta$?
      – William
      2 days ago






    • 1




      It is a pleasure. $cos2theta=bf Re e^2itheta$ and after substitution $e^itheta=z$ will be $cos2theta=bf Rez^2$. @William Also note that $bf Re z^2-isintheta=bf Re z^2$ .
      – user 108128
      2 days ago


















    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes








    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes








    up vote
    3
    down vote



    accepted










    If $varphi(x,y)=fracx^2-y^25+4x$, then your integral is$$int_0^2pivarphi(costheta,sintheta),mathrm dtheta.tag1$$Let$$f(z)=frac1zvarphileft(fracz+z^-12,fracz-z^-12iright)$$and$$beginarrayrcccgammacolon&[0,2pi]&longrightarrow&mathbb C\&theta&mapsto&e^itheta.endarray$$Then$$varphi(costheta,sintheta)=varphileft(frace^itheta+e^-itheta2,frace^itheta-e^-itheta2iright)=e^ithetafleft(e^ithetaright).$$Thereforebeginalign(1)&=frac1iint_0^2pie^-ithetavarphileft(frace^itheta+e^-itheta2,frace^itheta-e^-itheta2iright)ie^itheta,mathrm dtheta\&=-iint_gamma f(z),mathrm dz.endalignThis integral can be computed through the residue theorem: it is equal to$$2pisumoperatornameres_z=chibigl(f(z)bigr),tag2$$where the possible values of $chi$ are the poles of $f$ in the open unit circle. But$$f(z)=fracz^4+1z^2(4z^2+10z+4).$$So, $f$ has $3$ poles, two of which are located at the open unit circle: $0$ and $-frac12$ (the third one is $-2$) and the residue of $f$ at these points is $frac1724$ and $-frac58$ respectively. Therefore, your integral is equal to$$2pileft(frac1724-frac58right)=fracpi6.$$






    share|cite|improve this answer



























      up vote
      3
      down vote



      accepted










      If $varphi(x,y)=fracx^2-y^25+4x$, then your integral is$$int_0^2pivarphi(costheta,sintheta),mathrm dtheta.tag1$$Let$$f(z)=frac1zvarphileft(fracz+z^-12,fracz-z^-12iright)$$and$$beginarrayrcccgammacolon&[0,2pi]&longrightarrow&mathbb C\&theta&mapsto&e^itheta.endarray$$Then$$varphi(costheta,sintheta)=varphileft(frace^itheta+e^-itheta2,frace^itheta-e^-itheta2iright)=e^ithetafleft(e^ithetaright).$$Thereforebeginalign(1)&=frac1iint_0^2pie^-ithetavarphileft(frace^itheta+e^-itheta2,frace^itheta-e^-itheta2iright)ie^itheta,mathrm dtheta\&=-iint_gamma f(z),mathrm dz.endalignThis integral can be computed through the residue theorem: it is equal to$$2pisumoperatornameres_z=chibigl(f(z)bigr),tag2$$where the possible values of $chi$ are the poles of $f$ in the open unit circle. But$$f(z)=fracz^4+1z^2(4z^2+10z+4).$$So, $f$ has $3$ poles, two of which are located at the open unit circle: $0$ and $-frac12$ (the third one is $-2$) and the residue of $f$ at these points is $frac1724$ and $-frac58$ respectively. Therefore, your integral is equal to$$2pileft(frac1724-frac58right)=fracpi6.$$






      share|cite|improve this answer

























        up vote
        3
        down vote



        accepted







        up vote
        3
        down vote



        accepted






        If $varphi(x,y)=fracx^2-y^25+4x$, then your integral is$$int_0^2pivarphi(costheta,sintheta),mathrm dtheta.tag1$$Let$$f(z)=frac1zvarphileft(fracz+z^-12,fracz-z^-12iright)$$and$$beginarrayrcccgammacolon&[0,2pi]&longrightarrow&mathbb C\&theta&mapsto&e^itheta.endarray$$Then$$varphi(costheta,sintheta)=varphileft(frace^itheta+e^-itheta2,frace^itheta-e^-itheta2iright)=e^ithetafleft(e^ithetaright).$$Thereforebeginalign(1)&=frac1iint_0^2pie^-ithetavarphileft(frace^itheta+e^-itheta2,frace^itheta-e^-itheta2iright)ie^itheta,mathrm dtheta\&=-iint_gamma f(z),mathrm dz.endalignThis integral can be computed through the residue theorem: it is equal to$$2pisumoperatornameres_z=chibigl(f(z)bigr),tag2$$where the possible values of $chi$ are the poles of $f$ in the open unit circle. But$$f(z)=fracz^4+1z^2(4z^2+10z+4).$$So, $f$ has $3$ poles, two of which are located at the open unit circle: $0$ and $-frac12$ (the third one is $-2$) and the residue of $f$ at these points is $frac1724$ and $-frac58$ respectively. Therefore, your integral is equal to$$2pileft(frac1724-frac58right)=fracpi6.$$






        share|cite|improve this answer















        If $varphi(x,y)=fracx^2-y^25+4x$, then your integral is$$int_0^2pivarphi(costheta,sintheta),mathrm dtheta.tag1$$Let$$f(z)=frac1zvarphileft(fracz+z^-12,fracz-z^-12iright)$$and$$beginarrayrcccgammacolon&[0,2pi]&longrightarrow&mathbb C\&theta&mapsto&e^itheta.endarray$$Then$$varphi(costheta,sintheta)=varphileft(frace^itheta+e^-itheta2,frace^itheta-e^-itheta2iright)=e^ithetafleft(e^ithetaright).$$Thereforebeginalign(1)&=frac1iint_0^2pie^-ithetavarphileft(frace^itheta+e^-itheta2,frace^itheta-e^-itheta2iright)ie^itheta,mathrm dtheta\&=-iint_gamma f(z),mathrm dz.endalignThis integral can be computed through the residue theorem: it is equal to$$2pisumoperatornameres_z=chibigl(f(z)bigr),tag2$$where the possible values of $chi$ are the poles of $f$ in the open unit circle. But$$f(z)=fracz^4+1z^2(4z^2+10z+4).$$So, $f$ has $3$ poles, two of which are located at the open unit circle: $0$ and $-frac12$ (the third one is $-2$) and the residue of $f$ at these points is $frac1724$ and $-frac58$ respectively. Therefore, your integral is equal to$$2pileft(frac1724-frac58right)=fracpi6.$$







        share|cite|improve this answer















        share|cite|improve this answer



        share|cite|improve this answer








        edited Jul 24 at 14:11


























        answered Jul 24 at 13:58









        José Carlos Santos

        112k1696172




        112k1696172




















            up vote
            4
            down vote













            Use substitutions $z=e^itheta$ and $dtheta=dfracdziz$ then
            beginalign
            int_0^2pifrac cos(2theta) 5+4cos(theta), dtheta
            &= bf Reint_dfracz^25+4(z+1/z)dfracdziz \
            &= bf Redfrac1iint_dfracfracz^22(z+2)z+1/2dz \
            &= bf Redfrac1i2pi idfrac(-frac12)^23 \
            &= colorbluedfracpi6
            endalign






            share|cite|improve this answer























            • By "Re" do you mean Res(.) ? I always read Re as the real part. So just clearing things up
              – William
              Aug 2 at 13:33










            • It's real part.
              – user 108128
              Aug 2 at 13:34










            • sorry for the trouble again, but shouldn't the numerator be $z^2 - i sin theta$?
              – William
              2 days ago






            • 1




              It is a pleasure. $cos2theta=bf Re e^2itheta$ and after substitution $e^itheta=z$ will be $cos2theta=bf Rez^2$. @William Also note that $bf Re z^2-isintheta=bf Re z^2$ .
              – user 108128
              2 days ago















            up vote
            4
            down vote













            Use substitutions $z=e^itheta$ and $dtheta=dfracdziz$ then
            beginalign
            int_0^2pifrac cos(2theta) 5+4cos(theta), dtheta
            &= bf Reint_dfracz^25+4(z+1/z)dfracdziz \
            &= bf Redfrac1iint_dfracfracz^22(z+2)z+1/2dz \
            &= bf Redfrac1i2pi idfrac(-frac12)^23 \
            &= colorbluedfracpi6
            endalign






            share|cite|improve this answer























            • By "Re" do you mean Res(.) ? I always read Re as the real part. So just clearing things up
              – William
              Aug 2 at 13:33










            • It's real part.
              – user 108128
              Aug 2 at 13:34










            • sorry for the trouble again, but shouldn't the numerator be $z^2 - i sin theta$?
              – William
              2 days ago






            • 1




              It is a pleasure. $cos2theta=bf Re e^2itheta$ and after substitution $e^itheta=z$ will be $cos2theta=bf Rez^2$. @William Also note that $bf Re z^2-isintheta=bf Re z^2$ .
              – user 108128
              2 days ago













            up vote
            4
            down vote










            up vote
            4
            down vote









            Use substitutions $z=e^itheta$ and $dtheta=dfracdziz$ then
            beginalign
            int_0^2pifrac cos(2theta) 5+4cos(theta), dtheta
            &= bf Reint_dfracz^25+4(z+1/z)dfracdziz \
            &= bf Redfrac1iint_dfracfracz^22(z+2)z+1/2dz \
            &= bf Redfrac1i2pi idfrac(-frac12)^23 \
            &= colorbluedfracpi6
            endalign






            share|cite|improve this answer















            Use substitutions $z=e^itheta$ and $dtheta=dfracdziz$ then
            beginalign
            int_0^2pifrac cos(2theta) 5+4cos(theta), dtheta
            &= bf Reint_dfracz^25+4(z+1/z)dfracdziz \
            &= bf Redfrac1iint_dfracfracz^22(z+2)z+1/2dz \
            &= bf Redfrac1i2pi idfrac(-frac12)^23 \
            &= colorbluedfracpi6
            endalign







            share|cite|improve this answer















            share|cite|improve this answer



            share|cite|improve this answer








            edited Jul 24 at 14:24


























            answered Jul 24 at 14:13









            user 108128

            18.8k41544




            18.8k41544











            • By "Re" do you mean Res(.) ? I always read Re as the real part. So just clearing things up
              – William
              Aug 2 at 13:33










            • It's real part.
              – user 108128
              Aug 2 at 13:34










            • sorry for the trouble again, but shouldn't the numerator be $z^2 - i sin theta$?
              – William
              2 days ago






            • 1




              It is a pleasure. $cos2theta=bf Re e^2itheta$ and after substitution $e^itheta=z$ will be $cos2theta=bf Rez^2$. @William Also note that $bf Re z^2-isintheta=bf Re z^2$ .
              – user 108128
              2 days ago

















            • By "Re" do you mean Res(.) ? I always read Re as the real part. So just clearing things up
              – William
              Aug 2 at 13:33










            • It's real part.
              – user 108128
              Aug 2 at 13:34










            • sorry for the trouble again, but shouldn't the numerator be $z^2 - i sin theta$?
              – William
              2 days ago






            • 1




              It is a pleasure. $cos2theta=bf Re e^2itheta$ and after substitution $e^itheta=z$ will be $cos2theta=bf Rez^2$. @William Also note that $bf Re z^2-isintheta=bf Re z^2$ .
              – user 108128
              2 days ago
















            By "Re" do you mean Res(.) ? I always read Re as the real part. So just clearing things up
            – William
            Aug 2 at 13:33




            By "Re" do you mean Res(.) ? I always read Re as the real part. So just clearing things up
            – William
            Aug 2 at 13:33












            It's real part.
            – user 108128
            Aug 2 at 13:34




            It's real part.
            – user 108128
            Aug 2 at 13:34












            sorry for the trouble again, but shouldn't the numerator be $z^2 - i sin theta$?
            – William
            2 days ago




            sorry for the trouble again, but shouldn't the numerator be $z^2 - i sin theta$?
            – William
            2 days ago




            1




            1




            It is a pleasure. $cos2theta=bf Re e^2itheta$ and after substitution $e^itheta=z$ will be $cos2theta=bf Rez^2$. @William Also note that $bf Re z^2-isintheta=bf Re z^2$ .
            – user 108128
            2 days ago





            It is a pleasure. $cos2theta=bf Re e^2itheta$ and after substitution $e^itheta=z$ will be $cos2theta=bf Rez^2$. @William Also note that $bf Re z^2-isintheta=bf Re z^2$ .
            – user 108128
            2 days ago



            Comments

            Popular posts from this blog

            What is the equation of a 3D cone with generalised tilt?

            Relationship between determinant of matrix and determinant of adjoint?

            Color the edges and diagonals of a regular polygon