A Question About Square Roots And Exponent Laws
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
Why is it in math, $sqrtab$=$sqrta$$sqrtb$? I get why this is the case for any other power instead of $1/2$. For instance, if the power was for, then $(ab)^4$=$(a)^4$$(b)^4$ because on both sides, there will be 4 a's and 4 b's. But somehow, this proof doesn't seem as intuitive when used to prove that $sqrtab$=$sqrta$$sqrtb$. So can someone please prove/explain to me why $sqrtab$=$sqrta$$sqrtb$? Please don't do this too rigorously, just explain it at the level of a high school pre-calc student please.
algebra-precalculus exponentiation radicals
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
Why is it in math, $sqrtab$=$sqrta$$sqrtb$? I get why this is the case for any other power instead of $1/2$. For instance, if the power was for, then $(ab)^4$=$(a)^4$$(b)^4$ because on both sides, there will be 4 a's and 4 b's. But somehow, this proof doesn't seem as intuitive when used to prove that $sqrtab$=$sqrta$$sqrtb$. So can someone please prove/explain to me why $sqrtab$=$sqrta$$sqrtb$? Please don't do this too rigorously, just explain it at the level of a high school pre-calc student please.
algebra-precalculus exponentiation radicals
Perhaps because each has the same square?
– Dave L. Renfro
Jul 31 at 8:04
Fundamentally this depends on one of the properties of index that you studied about $(ab)^2=a^2b^2$
– daruma
Jul 31 at 8:04
Convince yourself that $(sqrtasqrtb)^2 = ab$.
– Good Morning Captain
Jul 31 at 8:04
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
Why is it in math, $sqrtab$=$sqrta$$sqrtb$? I get why this is the case for any other power instead of $1/2$. For instance, if the power was for, then $(ab)^4$=$(a)^4$$(b)^4$ because on both sides, there will be 4 a's and 4 b's. But somehow, this proof doesn't seem as intuitive when used to prove that $sqrtab$=$sqrta$$sqrtb$. So can someone please prove/explain to me why $sqrtab$=$sqrta$$sqrtb$? Please don't do this too rigorously, just explain it at the level of a high school pre-calc student please.
algebra-precalculus exponentiation radicals
Why is it in math, $sqrtab$=$sqrta$$sqrtb$? I get why this is the case for any other power instead of $1/2$. For instance, if the power was for, then $(ab)^4$=$(a)^4$$(b)^4$ because on both sides, there will be 4 a's and 4 b's. But somehow, this proof doesn't seem as intuitive when used to prove that $sqrtab$=$sqrta$$sqrtb$. So can someone please prove/explain to me why $sqrtab$=$sqrta$$sqrtb$? Please don't do this too rigorously, just explain it at the level of a high school pre-calc student please.
algebra-precalculus exponentiation radicals
edited Jul 31 at 15:42
Abcd
2,3151624
2,3151624
asked Jul 31 at 7:58


Ethan Chan
598322
598322
Perhaps because each has the same square?
– Dave L. Renfro
Jul 31 at 8:04
Fundamentally this depends on one of the properties of index that you studied about $(ab)^2=a^2b^2$
– daruma
Jul 31 at 8:04
Convince yourself that $(sqrtasqrtb)^2 = ab$.
– Good Morning Captain
Jul 31 at 8:04
add a comment |Â
Perhaps because each has the same square?
– Dave L. Renfro
Jul 31 at 8:04
Fundamentally this depends on one of the properties of index that you studied about $(ab)^2=a^2b^2$
– daruma
Jul 31 at 8:04
Convince yourself that $(sqrtasqrtb)^2 = ab$.
– Good Morning Captain
Jul 31 at 8:04
Perhaps because each has the same square?
– Dave L. Renfro
Jul 31 at 8:04
Perhaps because each has the same square?
– Dave L. Renfro
Jul 31 at 8:04
Fundamentally this depends on one of the properties of index that you studied about $(ab)^2=a^2b^2$
– daruma
Jul 31 at 8:04
Fundamentally this depends on one of the properties of index that you studied about $(ab)^2=a^2b^2$
– daruma
Jul 31 at 8:04
Convince yourself that $(sqrtasqrtb)^2 = ab$.
– Good Morning Captain
Jul 31 at 8:04
Convince yourself that $(sqrtasqrtb)^2 = ab$.
– Good Morning Captain
Jul 31 at 8:04
add a comment |Â
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
The statement is only true if $a, b geq 0$.
Let $a, b geq 0$. Let $u = sqrta$; let $v = sqrtb$. Since $sqrtx$ is the principal (nonnegative) square root of $x$, $u, v geq 0$, $u^2 = a$, $v^2 = b$.
beginalign*
sqrtab & = sqrtu^2v^2 && textsubstitution\
& = sqrtuuvv && textby definition\
& = sqrtu(uv)v && textassociativity of multiplication\
& = sqrtu(vu)v && textcommutativity of multiplication\
& = sqrt(uv)(uv) && textassociativity of multiplication\
& = sqrt(uv)^2 && textby definition\
& = |uv| && texttake principal square root\
& = uv && text = uv$\
& = sqrtasqrtb && textsubstitution
endalign*
1
Thank you, I get it now.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:28
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
Let $a,bge0$ (the version with complex numbers of this identity does not hold). By definition, you want to prove that $alpha=sqrt asqrt b$ is a non-negative real number such that $alpha^2=ab$. Since $sqrt a$ and $sqrt b$ are non-negative real numbers, $alpha$ is too. Finally, $alpha^2=left(sqrt asqrt bright)^2=left(sqrt aright)^2left(sqrt bright)^2=ab$.
But how does the fact that when they are squared, they yield the same results prove that they are the same? Because when -2 and 2 are squared, they are both equal to 2? But that doesn't mean they are the same.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:09
@EthanChan That's why I kept writing "non-negative" all those times, and why the definition of square root - or $sqrt[2n]bullet$, for that matter - explicitly requires the root to be the non-negative solution to the equation $t^2=a$. Since the map $xmapsto x^2$ (or $xmapsto x^2n$ with $nge 1$) is strictly increasing on $[0,infty)$, there is at most one such number in this interval.
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 8:13
Oh right, never mind. But then, how about for something like a cube root?
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:14
1
math.stackexchange.com/questions/1700731/…
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 10:22
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
First of all: it is not always $sqrtab=sqrtasqrtb$, there are some conditions you have to check first e.g. you want to have $a,bgeq 0$ or even more trivial $a,binmathbb R$ as the root of complex numbers turns out to be...well, rather complex to handle.
Assuming that all of these conditions are met and you accept the fact that $(xcdot y)^n=x^ncdot y^n$ for $ninmathbb N$ maybe the following helps you:
$$left(sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]yright)^n = sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]y = xcdot y=left(sqrt[n]xcdot yright)^n$$
Thus we have
$$left(sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]yright)^n =left(sqrt[n]xcdot yright)^n$$
which yields
$$sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]y=sqrt[n]xcdot y.$$
add a comment |Â
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
The statement is only true if $a, b geq 0$.
Let $a, b geq 0$. Let $u = sqrta$; let $v = sqrtb$. Since $sqrtx$ is the principal (nonnegative) square root of $x$, $u, v geq 0$, $u^2 = a$, $v^2 = b$.
beginalign*
sqrtab & = sqrtu^2v^2 && textsubstitution\
& = sqrtuuvv && textby definition\
& = sqrtu(uv)v && textassociativity of multiplication\
& = sqrtu(vu)v && textcommutativity of multiplication\
& = sqrt(uv)(uv) && textassociativity of multiplication\
& = sqrt(uv)^2 && textby definition\
& = |uv| && texttake principal square root\
& = uv && text = uv$\
& = sqrtasqrtb && textsubstitution
endalign*
1
Thank you, I get it now.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:28
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
The statement is only true if $a, b geq 0$.
Let $a, b geq 0$. Let $u = sqrta$; let $v = sqrtb$. Since $sqrtx$ is the principal (nonnegative) square root of $x$, $u, v geq 0$, $u^2 = a$, $v^2 = b$.
beginalign*
sqrtab & = sqrtu^2v^2 && textsubstitution\
& = sqrtuuvv && textby definition\
& = sqrtu(uv)v && textassociativity of multiplication\
& = sqrtu(vu)v && textcommutativity of multiplication\
& = sqrt(uv)(uv) && textassociativity of multiplication\
& = sqrt(uv)^2 && textby definition\
& = |uv| && texttake principal square root\
& = uv && text = uv$\
& = sqrtasqrtb && textsubstitution
endalign*
1
Thank you, I get it now.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:28
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
The statement is only true if $a, b geq 0$.
Let $a, b geq 0$. Let $u = sqrta$; let $v = sqrtb$. Since $sqrtx$ is the principal (nonnegative) square root of $x$, $u, v geq 0$, $u^2 = a$, $v^2 = b$.
beginalign*
sqrtab & = sqrtu^2v^2 && textsubstitution\
& = sqrtuuvv && textby definition\
& = sqrtu(uv)v && textassociativity of multiplication\
& = sqrtu(vu)v && textcommutativity of multiplication\
& = sqrt(uv)(uv) && textassociativity of multiplication\
& = sqrt(uv)^2 && textby definition\
& = |uv| && texttake principal square root\
& = uv && text = uv$\
& = sqrtasqrtb && textsubstitution
endalign*
The statement is only true if $a, b geq 0$.
Let $a, b geq 0$. Let $u = sqrta$; let $v = sqrtb$. Since $sqrtx$ is the principal (nonnegative) square root of $x$, $u, v geq 0$, $u^2 = a$, $v^2 = b$.
beginalign*
sqrtab & = sqrtu^2v^2 && textsubstitution\
& = sqrtuuvv && textby definition\
& = sqrtu(uv)v && textassociativity of multiplication\
& = sqrtu(vu)v && textcommutativity of multiplication\
& = sqrt(uv)(uv) && textassociativity of multiplication\
& = sqrt(uv)^2 && textby definition\
& = |uv| && texttake principal square root\
& = uv && text = uv$\
& = sqrtasqrtb && textsubstitution
endalign*
answered Jul 31 at 8:26
N. F. Taussig
38k93053
38k93053
1
Thank you, I get it now.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:28
add a comment |Â
1
Thank you, I get it now.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:28
1
1
Thank you, I get it now.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:28
Thank you, I get it now.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:28
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
Let $a,bge0$ (the version with complex numbers of this identity does not hold). By definition, you want to prove that $alpha=sqrt asqrt b$ is a non-negative real number such that $alpha^2=ab$. Since $sqrt a$ and $sqrt b$ are non-negative real numbers, $alpha$ is too. Finally, $alpha^2=left(sqrt asqrt bright)^2=left(sqrt aright)^2left(sqrt bright)^2=ab$.
But how does the fact that when they are squared, they yield the same results prove that they are the same? Because when -2 and 2 are squared, they are both equal to 2? But that doesn't mean they are the same.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:09
@EthanChan That's why I kept writing "non-negative" all those times, and why the definition of square root - or $sqrt[2n]bullet$, for that matter - explicitly requires the root to be the non-negative solution to the equation $t^2=a$. Since the map $xmapsto x^2$ (or $xmapsto x^2n$ with $nge 1$) is strictly increasing on $[0,infty)$, there is at most one such number in this interval.
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 8:13
Oh right, never mind. But then, how about for something like a cube root?
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:14
1
math.stackexchange.com/questions/1700731/…
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 10:22
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
Let $a,bge0$ (the version with complex numbers of this identity does not hold). By definition, you want to prove that $alpha=sqrt asqrt b$ is a non-negative real number such that $alpha^2=ab$. Since $sqrt a$ and $sqrt b$ are non-negative real numbers, $alpha$ is too. Finally, $alpha^2=left(sqrt asqrt bright)^2=left(sqrt aright)^2left(sqrt bright)^2=ab$.
But how does the fact that when they are squared, they yield the same results prove that they are the same? Because when -2 and 2 are squared, they are both equal to 2? But that doesn't mean they are the same.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:09
@EthanChan That's why I kept writing "non-negative" all those times, and why the definition of square root - or $sqrt[2n]bullet$, for that matter - explicitly requires the root to be the non-negative solution to the equation $t^2=a$. Since the map $xmapsto x^2$ (or $xmapsto x^2n$ with $nge 1$) is strictly increasing on $[0,infty)$, there is at most one such number in this interval.
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 8:13
Oh right, never mind. But then, how about for something like a cube root?
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:14
1
math.stackexchange.com/questions/1700731/…
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 10:22
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
up vote
2
down vote
Let $a,bge0$ (the version with complex numbers of this identity does not hold). By definition, you want to prove that $alpha=sqrt asqrt b$ is a non-negative real number such that $alpha^2=ab$. Since $sqrt a$ and $sqrt b$ are non-negative real numbers, $alpha$ is too. Finally, $alpha^2=left(sqrt asqrt bright)^2=left(sqrt aright)^2left(sqrt bright)^2=ab$.
Let $a,bge0$ (the version with complex numbers of this identity does not hold). By definition, you want to prove that $alpha=sqrt asqrt b$ is a non-negative real number such that $alpha^2=ab$. Since $sqrt a$ and $sqrt b$ are non-negative real numbers, $alpha$ is too. Finally, $alpha^2=left(sqrt asqrt bright)^2=left(sqrt aright)^2left(sqrt bright)^2=ab$.
answered Jul 31 at 8:04
Saucy O'Path
2,394217
2,394217
But how does the fact that when they are squared, they yield the same results prove that they are the same? Because when -2 and 2 are squared, they are both equal to 2? But that doesn't mean they are the same.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:09
@EthanChan That's why I kept writing "non-negative" all those times, and why the definition of square root - or $sqrt[2n]bullet$, for that matter - explicitly requires the root to be the non-negative solution to the equation $t^2=a$. Since the map $xmapsto x^2$ (or $xmapsto x^2n$ with $nge 1$) is strictly increasing on $[0,infty)$, there is at most one such number in this interval.
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 8:13
Oh right, never mind. But then, how about for something like a cube root?
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:14
1
math.stackexchange.com/questions/1700731/…
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 10:22
add a comment |Â
But how does the fact that when they are squared, they yield the same results prove that they are the same? Because when -2 and 2 are squared, they are both equal to 2? But that doesn't mean they are the same.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:09
@EthanChan That's why I kept writing "non-negative" all those times, and why the definition of square root - or $sqrt[2n]bullet$, for that matter - explicitly requires the root to be the non-negative solution to the equation $t^2=a$. Since the map $xmapsto x^2$ (or $xmapsto x^2n$ with $nge 1$) is strictly increasing on $[0,infty)$, there is at most one such number in this interval.
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 8:13
Oh right, never mind. But then, how about for something like a cube root?
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:14
1
math.stackexchange.com/questions/1700731/…
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 10:22
But how does the fact that when they are squared, they yield the same results prove that they are the same? Because when -2 and 2 are squared, they are both equal to 2? But that doesn't mean they are the same.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:09
But how does the fact that when they are squared, they yield the same results prove that they are the same? Because when -2 and 2 are squared, they are both equal to 2? But that doesn't mean they are the same.
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:09
@EthanChan That's why I kept writing "non-negative" all those times, and why the definition of square root - or $sqrt[2n]bullet$, for that matter - explicitly requires the root to be the non-negative solution to the equation $t^2=a$. Since the map $xmapsto x^2$ (or $xmapsto x^2n$ with $nge 1$) is strictly increasing on $[0,infty)$, there is at most one such number in this interval.
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 8:13
@EthanChan That's why I kept writing "non-negative" all those times, and why the definition of square root - or $sqrt[2n]bullet$, for that matter - explicitly requires the root to be the non-negative solution to the equation $t^2=a$. Since the map $xmapsto x^2$ (or $xmapsto x^2n$ with $nge 1$) is strictly increasing on $[0,infty)$, there is at most one such number in this interval.
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 8:13
Oh right, never mind. But then, how about for something like a cube root?
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:14
Oh right, never mind. But then, how about for something like a cube root?
– Ethan Chan
Jul 31 at 8:14
1
1
math.stackexchange.com/questions/1700731/…
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 10:22
math.stackexchange.com/questions/1700731/…
– Saucy O'Path
Jul 31 at 10:22
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
First of all: it is not always $sqrtab=sqrtasqrtb$, there are some conditions you have to check first e.g. you want to have $a,bgeq 0$ or even more trivial $a,binmathbb R$ as the root of complex numbers turns out to be...well, rather complex to handle.
Assuming that all of these conditions are met and you accept the fact that $(xcdot y)^n=x^ncdot y^n$ for $ninmathbb N$ maybe the following helps you:
$$left(sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]yright)^n = sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]y = xcdot y=left(sqrt[n]xcdot yright)^n$$
Thus we have
$$left(sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]yright)^n =left(sqrt[n]xcdot yright)^n$$
which yields
$$sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]y=sqrt[n]xcdot y.$$
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
First of all: it is not always $sqrtab=sqrtasqrtb$, there are some conditions you have to check first e.g. you want to have $a,bgeq 0$ or even more trivial $a,binmathbb R$ as the root of complex numbers turns out to be...well, rather complex to handle.
Assuming that all of these conditions are met and you accept the fact that $(xcdot y)^n=x^ncdot y^n$ for $ninmathbb N$ maybe the following helps you:
$$left(sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]yright)^n = sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]y = xcdot y=left(sqrt[n]xcdot yright)^n$$
Thus we have
$$left(sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]yright)^n =left(sqrt[n]xcdot yright)^n$$
which yields
$$sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]y=sqrt[n]xcdot y.$$
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
First of all: it is not always $sqrtab=sqrtasqrtb$, there are some conditions you have to check first e.g. you want to have $a,bgeq 0$ or even more trivial $a,binmathbb R$ as the root of complex numbers turns out to be...well, rather complex to handle.
Assuming that all of these conditions are met and you accept the fact that $(xcdot y)^n=x^ncdot y^n$ for $ninmathbb N$ maybe the following helps you:
$$left(sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]yright)^n = sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]y = xcdot y=left(sqrt[n]xcdot yright)^n$$
Thus we have
$$left(sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]yright)^n =left(sqrt[n]xcdot yright)^n$$
which yields
$$sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]y=sqrt[n]xcdot y.$$
First of all: it is not always $sqrtab=sqrtasqrtb$, there are some conditions you have to check first e.g. you want to have $a,bgeq 0$ or even more trivial $a,binmathbb R$ as the root of complex numbers turns out to be...well, rather complex to handle.
Assuming that all of these conditions are met and you accept the fact that $(xcdot y)^n=x^ncdot y^n$ for $ninmathbb N$ maybe the following helps you:
$$left(sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]yright)^n = sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]y = xcdot y=left(sqrt[n]xcdot yright)^n$$
Thus we have
$$left(sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]yright)^n =left(sqrt[n]xcdot yright)^n$$
which yields
$$sqrt[n]xcdotsqrt[n]y=sqrt[n]xcdot y.$$
answered Jul 31 at 8:07
Hirshy
4,32021336
4,32021336
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2867777%2fa-question-about-square-roots-and-exponent-laws%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Perhaps because each has the same square?
– Dave L. Renfro
Jul 31 at 8:04
Fundamentally this depends on one of the properties of index that you studied about $(ab)^2=a^2b^2$
– daruma
Jul 31 at 8:04
Convince yourself that $(sqrtasqrtb)^2 = ab$.
– Good Morning Captain
Jul 31 at 8:04